Although the majority of this blog deals with lighters and collecting of the vintage variety, the rapidly surmounting problems caused by the S.T. Dupont and Alfred Dunhill “knockoffs” that roam the internet these days are definitely worthy of a post. Feeding the misery of legitimate new lighter retailers, the fake lighters out there can be quite convincing to the untrained eye (and sometimes even the trained eye) prompting the accusation of retailers as being “rip-off artists”.
“I see the same lighter that you are selling for $695.00, on eBay for $295.00!” Yes, eBay seems to be the primary conduit for the reproductions, usually coming from such countries England, Singapore, Hong Kong, etc… The buyer will see the lighter for sale at an insanely low price that is too good to possibly pass up, buy it, and receive the lighter in a perfectly legal eBay transaction. The problem is that usually by the second or third filling of butane gas, the lighter mysteriously stops working.
How many depressed or outraged customers we’ve had at our repair service with one of these knock-offs is impossible to say. Some get really angry and storm out. Some get that low, “I’ve been suckered” look across their faces. Others roll their eyes in the realization that the lighter they received as a gift was not so impressive as previously thought. But regardless of the reaction, all know they are victims of a scam with a worthless piece of junk.
At first we could only tell the real from the fake upon taking them apart and observing the internal parts. However, subtle and not-so-subtle clues have made themselves apparent over the months that I will point out to you here. Please understand though, the Dupont fakes are, for the most part, REALLY good fakes. The Dunhill’s are sometimes passable, other times laughable.
ST Dupont
Showing you the front, back, sides or top of a Dupont is pointless as it is nearly impossible to tell the real from the faux. However, the bottom of the lighters reveal the important clues.
Can you tell the difference? Of course you can’t, and this is the main problem with using this to identify authenticity in these lighters; you’ve got to have pretty good eyesight and attention for detail.
Here’s a close-up (click the picture to see it full size):

See any difference yet? Which one do you think is real? If you said the one on the right…
…you’d be absolutely wrong.
The lighter on the left is the real Dupont. Dupont lighters are finished by hand, and the lighter on the right looks too perfect to be real. Specifically, the serial number/letter combo on the bottom there is the dead giveaway. See how the code on the left is kind of slanted, and the characters are uneven in relation to one another? The characters on the right are lined up like good little soldiers. Too perfect=bad.
Dunhill

This one is a little more obvious–fitting snugly into the “laughable” category as far a Dunhill reproductions are concerned. Anyone who has ever owned a Dunhill butane lighter before will easily recognize the characteristic keyhole-shaped screw on the lower-right of the lighter on the right of this picture. The thumb button in the center is also a dead-giveaway, but be cautious because some of the newest Dunhill lighters no longer have this feature, instead opting for the pull bar screw handle that is more characteristic of the Dupont lighters, and unfortunately represented by the fake lighter on the left.
Of course the problem here is how on earth do you determine what the serial numbers and thumb-screws and pull bars look like when buying a new lighter on eBay? You don’t. If it looks like an incredible deal on a new lighter, it’s on eBay, it’s not from a legitimate reseller of Dupont and Dunhill products, chances are that it’s not a “real” lighter. For Dupont lighters, you can contact Colibri (they import ST Dupont lighters) at 401-943-2100 to verify if a particular store is a legitimate reseller. Dunhill is a little harder (unfortunately).
We are legitimate resellers of Alfred Dunhill and S.T. Dupont lighters. Our websites: Elegantlighters.com and Vintagelighters.com.
Remember the old saying: “If it seems too good to be true, it probably is.” I Couldn’t have said it better myself.